Where There is Injustice, There is Silence


A Guest Post by: Rev. Kris Van Engen 

Sometimes silence speaks. Sometimes silence kills.

I’ve been in the position of a congregational justice mobilizer for two years now and if I’ve learned anything, it is that silence plus lies (or the more congenial term “myths”) equals oppression. We all know this simple equation is true but we are strangely drawn to it.


While Martin Luther King sat in a jail in Birmingham, his elders sent him a letter telling him to be quiet and leave the segregation issue to the courts. When AIDS was becoming an epidemic in the 1980s, the stigma was on the victims; discussing how to change the situation was considered akin to condoning sin. Pick a modern issue of injustice and surely you will find groups who, in spite of having the power to be heard, remain silent–maybe because of uncertainty, maybe to stay neutral, maybe to be a good listener, maybe for good or bad intentions. At any rate, where there is injustice, there is silence.

The scenario is as true on a small scale as it is on a large scale. Consider the family with an abusive parent. The child is scolded, “What happens in our house is nobody else’s business.” The spouse defends the abuser to critics, “Well, if our son watched his behavior he wouldn’t have these problems.” The critics say, “Oh, I guess it’s more complicated than I thought.” The abuse continues. The child waits for someone to ride in and speak the truth. The victims of AIDS, preventable famine, changing climate, racism, and needless deportations wait with him.


We celebrate Jesus’ birth into a land of silence and lies. The threat of his voice moved Herod to put an early ransom on his head. This is the brave voice our world needs. Jesus doesn’t fall into the temptation of silence like we do. The spirit of the Lord is on him. He sees through the myths. He is anointed to proclaim good news to the poor.

Of course, Jesus himself was silent from time to time. The most notable occasion, shortly after sharing the last supper bread and wine with his disciples, was remaining speechless before Herod. It was the death of him. A temporary death that resulted in new life.

This would become Jesus’ gift to us. Light shed on a dark scene. If we are victims, he stands with us. If we need certainty mixed with courage to break from the ranks of neutrality, he offers it through the Holy Spirit, his word, and the communion of saints. He is the prince who replaces injustice with peace.

In this new year, what is an opportunity you could take to SPEAK? 


KrisKris Van Engen is the Congregational Justice Mobilizer for the Office of Social Justice and World Renew. He equips people as they act on Jesus’ instructions to be peacemakers, to do justice, and to prevent the root causes of poverty and hunger. You can read his article Social Justice 101 here. 

Kris previously worked for 10 years as a pastor and church ministries director. He and his wife Lisa have two children, Ellie and Josiah.

Contact Kris by email at kvanengen@crcna.org.


6 thoughts on “Where There is Injustice, There is Silence

  1. In Ireland there’s a saying – ‘Whatever you say, say nothing.’ It’s a sort of a joke nowadays but comes from an oppressed mentality where it was dangerous to speak because of very real fear of repercussion. 800 years of occupation takes it’s toll on a society!

    There are generally two main reasons for silence – one is to protect the status quo because it is believed it is advantageous to protect it, and the other is because of fear. Both usually share the view that the status quo can’t be changed anyway and it’s better to a) fit in or b) avoid conflict. In ‘Pedagogy of the Oppressed’ Paolo Freire points out that this happens because ‘the oppressed’ split off and come to identify with the oppressive status quo and that this stops them feeling they can act on it to change it, even when they don’t believe it is working. That is why, so often, we just get regime changes without any real social change – the oppressed just become the oppressors because they don’t see that there is an alternative to the status quo.

    Nice post – sorry for the long comment!

  2. This “speaks” volumes to me. I think people often stay quiet for fear of being judged themselves. (better to be silent than thought a fool…) It takes courage, and strength to speak up; especially if you’re alone in your words. But, like you said, Jesus is our strength, our hope, our courage…. all we need. He is more than enough. He is everything.
    Thanks for the challenge, Kris! I will look for opportunities to speak, or even shout. “If God is for us; who could be against us?”
    P.S You’re an EXCELLENT writer! 🙂

Thank you so much for your comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s